What was your very first success?

[ChattyGirl247]

i think mine was JK rowling

[chameleon24]

Through mail: Elijah Wood. It was pre-Lord of the Rings. I was so excited when i got the autograph, i totally freaked out.

In-person: I think it was Jim Thome back when he played for Cleveland. Pretty much my only in-person ones are baseball players except for my Panic! at the Disco one i got last summer.

[mstrfisto]

My first was in person Joe Theisman - at a signing when i was a kid.
ttm - Alyssa Milano pp via email
first personalized - Scott Hinds (Nien Numb in ROTS) - I got a personalized b+w photo and a personalized typed letter all via email!
First not via email - Steve Largent

[macaoidh]

My first success was from James Earl Jones.

[Peyton]

great question!

first IP: Johnathan Rand author of Michigan and American Chillers at a book signing

first TTM: Mitchel Musso from Hannah Montana, for my sister

first PP: Chauncey Billups of the Detroit Pistons

[aczkolwiek]

Full set of pre-prints from B. Monachium
I hate it, because I don't like this team and I only asked for authentic Lukasz Podolski's autograph that I like and respect. I followed instructions on their website and I wrote, that I will wait longer, but I want to receive authentic and only this one.
They didn't understand and I still don't have autograph I wanted to have

[darkthrone]

my first ttm was heidi klum in 1999. took exactly a week, i was floored! have to admit i really didn't think it would work when i sent off the request. glad i was wrong!

[writergirl123]

Skye McCole Bartusiak!

[eric]

first IP: Kristy Swanson

first TTM: Sarah Michelle Gellar

[vhorizon81]

In person: Joey Gamache (boxer from Maine)

TTM: Henry Ian Cusick