I sent 2 baseball cards, a L.O.R. and a S.A.S.E. to Mr. John Smiley on 11/13/13 using the address in the database. On 12/07/13, My letter and both baseball cards were sent back to me with a note on the letter reading: "John is unable to sign at this time because he is in the process of moving&q...

I sent Mr. John Offerdahl 2 Football Cards, L.O.R. and a S.A.S.E. on 11/29/13. I received 1 of my cards back fairly quickly on 12/28/13. I received only 1 card back autographed. Unfortunately I didn't get back my second football card at all. But it was well worth trading 1 unsigned football card for...

I sent Mr. Jimmy Key 2 baseball cards, L.O.R. and a S.A.S.E. I sent my request on 11/29/13. I received my cards back very fast on 12/14/13. He autographed 1 card for me (a 1988 Topps All Star card) but sent the second card back unsigned. I used the address in the database. I was very grateful for th...

Maybe I came into the convo late or missed something before. Why exactly would you send this guy a card of a different player or different sport? Im confused. I really appreciate you explainimg it. Thank you!

Just for my own curiosity, what card did you get signed? He played for a lot of teams. Just curious

Awesome! I really like hearing about ball players who return autographs, without asking for a fee or donation. Great looking card too! Congrats and thanks for sharing with all if us!

Thanks for sharing with us! I am a very big sports cards and sports memorabilia/autograph collector. Great success! Congrats!

It may not apply in this situation, but I know with some celebrities and fan mail addresses, a large percentage of requests are sent back because of the large amount of requests they get. I wouldn't give up, I sent the same request 3 times to a retired Baseball player, all 3 times were sent back uns...

As a sports cards/memorabilia and autograph collector myself, I have to say that this is really really cool! What an awesome item to have autographed. Congrats. How long did it take for you to get it back, if you don't mind me asking?

Hulk is actually really good about his fans and fan mail. In my experience...