Lucky! I just received a helmet today I sent to him last Tuesday. I used the stadium address since I don't know the private one. This was the second time I tried sending one to him, and both came back unsigned. I even included a $25 donation to his foundation this time.

jbwesterfield wrote:Lots of Peyton failures starting to pour in. I'm glad I sent mine earlier this season.
Sorry about yours.

It's aright, thanks. I figured I'd give it a shot. I saw all the failures posted after I sent mine out. Did you send a donation to his charity by chance?

I sent a mini helmet to Peyton Manning on October 24, 2013. I received the helmet back today (11-16-13) unsigned. There was a preprint picture of him that was with the helmet. It got damaged and I just threw it away after I took the picture. The address I used was: 13655 Broncos Parkway Englewood, C...

Very nice! I sent him a Broncos mini helmet last week!

I sent a mini helmet and rookie card to Eddie Lacy in the end of August. I received both back signed last week.

I have a sports illustrated in front of me that was signed in person by eddie lacy last Tuesday nite-it sure looks like a match to me, every auto is a little bit different, due to what they sign on, but his auto matches especially on his card to my magazine. I have a Leaf card that was pulled from ...

Sent: 8/29/13
Received: 10/22/13

Address used:

Attn: Eddie Lacy
P.O. Box 10628
Green Bay, WI 54307-0628

I sent the helmet and rookie card in same package. Eddie was kind of enough to sign both and send them back!

Haven't had any luck with Clay Matthews. I had success with Roethlisberger, but that was during his rookie year. I've had success with Jordy Nelson, Calvin Johnson, Bart Starr (with a donation), and Aaron Rodgers. Rodgers was pure luck and I know he doesn't sign TTM anymore.

I sent a mini helmet to Jordy Nelson last Tuesday (8.27) and received it back signed today! Very fast turnaround of only 8 days. He did not sign or send back a card that I included with the helmet. I don't mind that because the helmet was my main concern. http://i.imgur.com/nIkQUnr.jpg Address I use...

I sent a mini helmet to him last year and he returned it signed in about 9 days. He is really good about signing TTM.